RK was surely having a bit of private fun with that title, for there is something about ‘Thrown Away’ that feels positively tossed off. It’s executed with an immense care to appear merely anecdotal. At the end of it you’re left thinking, dizzily, How could anything that light pack such a punch? Half a notebook later, you’re still unpacking its symmetries. This has to be, surely, one of the most highly organised stories in the language.
A sheltered young colonial officer arrives in India, and takes everything about the place far too seriously. Having got himself into various romantic and financial scrapes, none of them career-ending, he kills himself — as sheltered, over-serious men tend to do — and then it’s up to his Major and the narrator to manufacture him a more fitting death (cholera will do), so as to comfort and protect his parents.
Kipling’s early diagnosis of The Boy’s condition (his early upbringing has “killed him dead” before he even arrives) is so striking, and is played out with such ghastly aplomb, it’s easy to forget that it’s only half of the story’s machinery. The rest involves the Major and the narrator, burning the bed, burying the body, scaring off the neighbours, in tears one minute, pissing themselves with laughter the next, because honestly, The Boy’s death is farce, not tragedy, and if there were any mercy in the world it should be possible to wake him up and tell him so.
But there isn’t.
So there you are.
All you have is your decency, which, to maintain, you sometimes have to do the silliest things.
First published in Plain Tales from the Hills, Thacker, Spink and Company, Calcutta, 1888, and available in Collected Stories, Everyman, 1994